CAJA Abroad
CAJA is unique because of the direct personal relationships we have
with people on the ground in the countries we work in. We have solid
sister relationships to organizations in Colombia and are currenlty
building contacts in Venezuela. CAJA members travel the world building
solidarity and momentum for a movement of social change. Here you can
read about the experiences first-hand as reported by CAJA members.
Updates from Colombia
Updates from Venezuela
Updates from Colombia
June 9, 2007--Putting the Spin on Repression
Dear friends,
Luis Albeiro Duran was last seen alive by his family on May 29 went
he left for work. I accompanied the family and members of the Low-Income
Women's Organization (OFP) to search for him in the Arenal neighborhood
of Barrancabermeja on June 4.
His spouse Nely, mother Elisabeth, father Luis, and the women of the
OFP went house-to-house in Arenal - showing his photo and asking for
help in finding him. The neighborhood is controlled by the right-wing
paramilitaries and most of the people were afraid to provide any information.
Finally, one young man said that Luis Albeiro had been grabbed by a
group of men in Arenal the evening of May 29. Later on, six shots were
fired. People ran to see what had happened but armed men kept them away
from the site where the shots had been fired. The body was then dumped
into a branch of the Magdalena River that runs alongside the neighborhood.
Wilson, a reporter with Caracol television, took out his radio and called
Civil Defense (search and rescue). He held out the radio so that Luis
could hear the conversation. Members of the Civil Defense had found
two bodies that day alongside the Magdalena River. Luis described what
his son was wearing when he left the house and that he had a heart tattoo
on his right shoulder. The Civil Defense responded that one of the bodies
had a similar tattoo.
"It's him! It's him!" cried out Luis. Gloria (a leader of
the OFP) held Elizabeth as sobbing wracked her body. Nely ran a few
steps and another member of the OFP put an arm around her. "The
children will never see him again!" she cried for Sharia (their
six-year-old daughter) and Jordan (eight-year-old son).
Although the Civil Defense members had found Luis Albeiro's body, they
hadn't bothered to retrieve it. We traveled with his family down the
Magdalena River to Boca de Sogamoso - the area where Civil Defense reported
finding the body. The boat wasn't able to enter the shallow channel
there and we turned back as it started to get dark.
Gloria returned to that area with three Civil Defense members the following
morning and they brought the body back for burial in Barrancabermeja.
She said it appeared that Luis Albeiro had been tortured.
Gloria also said that alias "Cenizo" was implicated in the
killing. He's the hired killer that works with the paramilitaries in
Arenal. "Everyone knows about Cenizo except, apparently, the police"
she said.
The Colombian government recently hired the public relations firm of
Burson-Marsteller to lobby congress for continued military aid and to
approve the "free trade" agreement between Colombia and the
U.S. The firm is headed by Mark Penn - a former Bill Clinton pollster
who is a top advisor to Hillary Clinton. The government also hired the
Glover Park Group which includes Joe Lockhart - a former Clinton White
House spokesman. Wal-Mart, Citigroup, and Caterpillar have joined this
effort in their role as co-chairs of the Latin American Trade Coalition.
Bill Clinton pushed through congress a massive increase in U.S.
military aid for Colombia in 2000. The paramilitaries, with support
from the police and military, took over Barrancabermeja just a few months
later.
Last night (June 8) in New York City, Clinton was presented with the
"Colombia is Passion" award by Colombian president Alvaro
Uribe. Clinton described Colombia as "the oldest democracy in Latin
America." The people here in Barrancabermeja that are suffering
from paramilitary violence have yet to enjoy that "democracy."
In love and solidarity,
Scott
Community Action for Justice in the Americas
May 16, 2007--Anniversary of the Barrancabermeja Massacre
Dear friends,
I returned to Colombia on May 16 - the anniversary of the Barrancabermeja
massacre. On May 16, 1998, a paramilitary death squad entered the southeast
part of this city. They killed seven people and took away 25 others
- who were never seen again. The paramilitaries had the cooperation
of the military and police which enabled them to carry out the massacre
without encountering any problems.
Two years later, Bill Clinton pushed through Congress a massive increase
in U.S. military aid to Colombia. He then waived the majority of human
rights conditions that Congress had attached to the aid, citing reasons
of "national security," in order to disburse those funds in
August 2000. Four months later, the paramilitaries took over Barrancabermeja.
On June 8, Colombian president Alvaro Uribe will honor Clinton with
the "Colombia is Passion" award in New York City. Uribe is
traveling to the U.S. to lobby for continued military aid and for the
passage of a "free trade" agreement with the U.S.
I arrived here in Barrancabermeja on May 24 and attended the weekly
meeting of the Barrancabermeja Association of Human Rights Activists
that afternoon. Hours earlier, the police used percussion grenades and
teargas to violently breakup a land recovery organized by the Barrancabermeja
Association of Displaced Persons (Asodesamuba). The Association represents
families that have been forced to flee from their homes in the countryside
and have sought refuge in the city.
On May 23, more than 100 of those families peacefully occupied a vacant
city lot in order to pressure the mayor, Edgard Cote, to take action
to resolve the desperate situation of the displaced in Barrancabermeja.
Riot police arrived there at 4 A.M. on May 24. The people responded
by sitting down and singing the national anthem. Police fired percussion
grenades and teargas, and began beating people. Three people were hospitalized,
including a three-month-old girl, and the families were forced to abandon
the lot.
I met with Socorro, the president of Asodesamuba, the following day.
Two men on a motorcycle had been repeatedly driving past the office
and she was concerned for her safety. The mayor had also filed a criminal
complaint against Socorro and the entire board of the Association for
"land invasion."
She said this was in retaliation for the complaint Asodesamuba had
filed against the mayor for corruption in the use of municipal funds
for the displaced and for his ties with the paramilitaries.
Lilia is the president of the Middle Magdalena Association of Victims
of Government Violence (Asorvim). The Association organized a series
of events to commemorate the anniversary of the Barrancabermeja massacre.
Lilia told me how her husband was killed by the paramilitaries in front
of their four children. "He took 12 shots standing up and they
shot him seven more times after he hit the ground." She also described
how her brother was detained and disappeared by the army - she found
his body 16 months later. "I do this work so that they're not forgotten
and so that other families won't suffer this same violence. I've learned
how to take life's hard blows and still be able to laugh."
Yaneth Perez, president of the Dawn of Women for Arauca Association,
did an amazing job during her Montana and Northwest speaking tour in
April. She gave 35 presentations in 17 communities to 1,300 people!
She got extensive media coverage and we raised more than $2,500 for
the Association!
Thanks to everyone who made the tour such a success.
In love and solidarity,
Scott
Community Action for Justice in the Americas
March 12, 2007--Inspiration of Women's Day
Dear friends,
While the men with guns are continuing to kill people, more than 200
women gathered together here in Saravena on March 8 to commemorate International
Women’s Day and to call for peace with justice. It was a very
beautiful and inspiring event!
The Dawn of Women for Arauca Association organized the commemoration
and issued an excellent declaration. The women denounced the atrocities
being committed by the U.S.-sponsored military and by the guerrillas.
They also expressed their deep commitment to continue working non-violently
to achieve peace with social justice.
U.S. military aid has caused “the poisoning of the land, murder,
massacres, threats, and the forced displacement and mass imprisonment
of community leaders and people in general” declared the women.
“Tactics of war that are intended to destroy the social networks
that have been created by the communities and open the way for the corporations
to implement large-scale infrastructure projects, plunder our resources,
and violate the most basic rights of the civilian population. The result
is hunger, despair, and desolation in our countryside.”
The women also had the courage and integrity to denounce the atrocities
being committed in the war between the two guerrilla groups here in
the state of Arauca. The FARC and ELN have “destroyed community-organized
economic projects, caused thousands of peasants to flee from their homes,
killed hundreds of people, raped women, and sown terror in the Araucan
countryside. The two organizations that said they took up arms to defend
the people are now killing those people.”
The women commemorated Morelly Guillin, nurse; Luz Miryam Farias, indigenous
teacher; and Maritza Linares—who have been killed in Arauca. They
also remembered Gloria Medina, Raquel Castro, Elida Parra, Dora Lizcano,
Fidelia Villamizar, Miriam Carrillo, Doris Garcia, Luz Perly Csrdoba,
Flor Naranjo, and Martha Osorio—Arauca community activists who
have been imprisoned.
“Mothers, daughters, sisters, aunts, friends, indigenous and black
women: Today we want to give you the recognition you deserve. You have
cultivated this ground with your blood and sacrifice. We will continue
to sow this land so that one day in the not-too-distant future the fruit
of our dreams will rise up from this ground.”
The women continued: “The Dawn of Women for Arauca Association
works to build the just world that we long for so deeply. A world in
which all of us will have a dignified life. A world in which we can
dream. A world in which we can live.”
While the women were making the final revisions to their declaration,
the army was torturing and killing Javier Zuqiga a few miles outside
of Saravena on the evening of March 7. He was a 29-year-old taxi driver
who left behind a 22-year-old wife and a 14-month-old daughter. The
army reported on March 9 that he was a guerrilla who had been killed
in combat.
Three days after International Women’s Day, George W. Bush stopped
in Bogotá for a seven-hour visit. Bush said to Colombian president
Uribe during the toast at lunch, _We value your democracy, and I thank
you for your firm leadership._
In love and solidarity,
Scott
Community Action for Justice in the Americas
February 25, 2007--This Insane War
Dear friends,
“I’d like information about the killings that occurred
in Tame County from Thursday through Monday” said Yilson, a leader
of the Joel Sierra Human Rights Foundation, as he called the Tame police
station. He noted the name, location, and date of each of the killings.
“Just those four?” he confirmed after receiving the information.
Yilson and Sonia also called the police stations in Saravena, Fortzl,
and Arauquita. Seven people had been killed in those counties from Thursday
February 15 to Monday February 19. There are only 175,000 people in
the four counties that comprise the western half of the state of Arauca.
The situation had been “relatively calm” since I returned
here to Arauca on January 26—that calm has now ended. The leaders
of the Foundation believe that the majority of the recent killings were
caused by the insane war being waged between the two guerrilla groups
(FARC and ELN) in Arauca. Both groups have been threatening and killing
civilians that they view as supporting the other side.
We drove through the epicenter of this war (Botalsn, La Horqueta, Alto
Cauca, and Pueblo Seco) on our way to Pueblo Nuevo on February 17. That
was the shortest route and the report was that the situation was still
calm. Four hours after we passed through Botalsn, fighting erupted between
the guerrilla groups. Two men on a motorcycle didn’t hear the
gunfire because of their helmets and the sound of the exhaust. They
rode into the crossfire and the man on back was killed. Another man
was killed in La Horqueta the following day.
“Alto Cauca and Pueblo Seco used to be full of people on Saturday
and Sunday,” said Ismael as we stopped for a soda in Pueblo Seco
at noon that Saturday. We were the only customers in the open-air bar
and there were very few people on the main street. Many people have
abandoned their homes and farms because they fear being killed in the
war between the guerrilla groups _ both of which profess to be fighting
for social justice.
This battle in Arauca was the cover story of the weekly magazine Cambio
on February 5 (see attached photo). The fight between the two groups
has now spread to other parts of the country and that was the cover
story of Semana magazine that same week.
Both guerrilla groups have stated that they oppose foreign corporations
exploiting Colombia’s natural resources. The war between those
groups here in Arauca has been going on for almost a year. During that
time, Occidental Petroleum (a U.S. corporation) and Repsol (a Spanish
corporation) have been jointly drilling for oil in the Cosecha field;
and Repsol has been drilling for oil in the Capachos and San Miguel
fields, and the Catleya field (in the territory of the U’Wa indigenous
people just west of Arauca). The fighting has temporarily shut down
the Arauca social movement and prevented any protest against the environmental,
cultural, and social destruction being caused by this drilling.
All of the social organizations here in Arauca have repeatedly called
on the guerrilla groups to stop targeting civilians in their insane
war against each other. “¡Ya basta! ¡Dejen a la población
civil fuera del conflicto!” (“That’s enough! Leave
the civilian population out of the
fight!”)
In love and solidarity,
Scott
Community Action for Justice in the Americas
January 29, 2007 – Cover-up of a Killing
Dear friends,
I returned to Saravena (in the northeastern state of Arauca) with a
national and international commission on January 26. We went to the
community of La Chucua the following day to investigate the killing
of Juan Pablo Verdugo and Santiago Hernandez by the Colombian military
on January 6.
We met with the families of Juan Pablo and Santiago in the open-air
restaurant and bar where they had gathered together to celebrate Los
Reyes (when the wise men visited the infant Jesus). We’ve decided
not to mention their names in this report because of the risks they
face for denouncing the killing.
The families told us that three men entered the restaurant around 11:30
P.M. The men had been identifying themselves as members of the Black
Eagles paramilitary group and were threatening and extorting the peasants
in the area. When the men left, Juan Pablo and Santiago followed them
out to the road to see where they were going. Soldiers were entrenched
on the opposite side of the road and there was a burst of gunfire.
Soldiers then ran into the restaurant accompanied by the three men –
who now had automatic weapons. The soldiers ordered the families to
lie down on the floor. One of Juan Pablo’s brothers is blind and
he didn’t get down on the floor. A soldier began to severely beat
him. Another of Juan Pablo’s brothers grabbed the soldier from
behind to try to halt the beating. A soldier hit him with a rifle butt
and threatened to kill him – pointing the rifle at his head. “After
what you’ve done to my brother and cousin go ahead and kill me!”
he responded.
Juan Pablo’s sister-in-law heard a corporal tell one of the soldiers,
“We have to get the people inside because we have to do this thing.”
The soldiers then ordered the families to go inside the kitchen. She
and her husband initially refused to do so because they were concerned
that the soldiers would plant something on the bodies of Juan Pablo
and Santiago in order to justify the killing. The sister-in-law saw
one of the soldiers suddenly approach Juan Pablo’s body. She yelled,
“Don’t put that thing on him!”
There was another burst of gunfire – apparently an attempt to
make it appear as though there had been fighting between the soldiers
and guerrillas. The soldiers ordered the families to stay inside and
they weren’t able to see the bodies of Juan Pablo and Santiago
until the morning. There was a revolver alongside each of the bodies.
A military spokesman said over the news radio that two guerrillas had
been killed in combat.
Juan Pablo was 28 years old and had two sons – eight and twelve
years old. Santiago was 31 years old. His brother introduced me to Santiago’s
five children. Yulitza is two years old, Joheny is four, Anderson turned
eight three weeks after his father’s death, Heily is eleven, and
Yeimer had her thirteenth birthday two days before her father was killed.
“It nearly broke my soul” (“Casi me partió
el alma.”) is the phrase that again describes how I felt.
The military had captured the three men that entered the restaurant
just one week before the killings. The families would like to know why
the three men were with the military that night. The families also want
the truth to be known – Juan Pablo and Santiago were not guerrillas
and they were not killed in combat.
In love and solidarity,
Scott
November 1, 2006—Repression in Saravena
Dear friends,
The military and police rounded up more than 120 people here in Saravena,
Arauca on October 27 and 28. Twenty of those people were taken to Arauca
City and charged with “rebellion.” My friend, Eduardo Sogamoso,
was detained by the police on October 27 and released later that night
on the outskirts of Saravena. The police and army searched the house
of my friend, Victor Laguado, on October 28 and sought to arrest him.
I learned about the detentions and arrests that evening and flew back
here from Bogotá the next day. The prosecutor’s office
then searched the offices of the Saravena Community Water Company and
the Sarare Cooperative on October 31.
Eduardo is the president of the Regional Student and Youth Organization,
ASOJER. His partner, Sonia Lopez, works for the Joel Sierra Regional
Human Rights Committee and we organized a Northwest speaking tour for
her last year. Sonia told me that Eduardo was detained by the police
at 8:30 P.M. on October 27 and brought to the police station. When she
arrived at the station, she was told that he was being taken to the
Saravena military base. Moments later, Eduardo called to tell her that
the police had forced him out of the truck near the northwest edge of
town. The military base is located in the opposite direction outside
the southeast part of Saravena. Sonia told me that if she hadn’t
gone to the police station to ask about Eduardo, the police probably
would have taken him out of town and he could have been killed. Eduardo
has fled from their home and is now in hiding.
Victor is a leader of the Sarare Cooperative (Coagrosarare) and a coordinator
of the Arauca social organizations. He has also been very active in
the campaign against Occidental Petroleum for the social and environmental
destruction caused by the corporation in Arauca. Victor’s partner,
Martha, was detained by the police in April 2005. Their house was searched
that evening and Victor was struck in the face by the police. Victor
wasn’t at home when the police and army searched their house again
on October 28 and there is an arrest order out for him.
The police set up a checkpoint in front of the Saravena Community Water
Company, ECAAS, at 8:30 A.M. on October 31. Five agents from the prosecutor’s
office then arrived and demanded to speak with my friend, Ariela, who
is the director. The search warrant stated that illegal activity was
being carried out in the company. I heard about the search and arrived
there 15 minutes later. There were four policemen inside the office
– all armed with automatic rifles and two wearing bullet proof
vests. The agents spent six hours searching the records of the company.
ECAAS is a very inspiring water company that is owned and managed by
the people of Saravena. It has suffered a lot of repression –
three members of the board were killed in 2003, and 12 workers were
imprisoned in 2002 and 2003.
The same agents then went to the Sarare Cooperative at 4:30 P.M. That
search warrant also stated that illegal activity was being carried out
in the cooperative. Sonia and I heard about the search and we arrived
there 15 minutes later. I took photos of the police in front of the
cooperative while one of the policemen filmed me. The agents spent two
and a half hours searching the records of the cooperative. The Sarare
Cooperative has 43 community stores and seeks to provide basic goods
at affordable prices for the peasants of Arauca.
We’re discussing the best way for you to respond to this wave
of repression in Saravena and we’ll try to send out an action
alert soon.
In love and solidarity,
Scott
September 3, 2006 -- The Crime of Clean Water
Dear friends,
Leidy is a 24-year-old microbiologist who has the very subversive job
of being the manager of the water treatment plant for the Saravena Community
Water Company (ECAAS). I visited the plant on August 28 and Leidy and
her co-workers spoke with understandable pride about this amazing community-owned-and-managed
company. Unfortunately, the Colombian government and military don’t
share this pride in ECAAS – they view it as a guerrilla project
that needs to be handed over to a private corporation.
ECAAS was created by the people of Saravena in 1970 and it provides
clean drinking water to approximately 20,000 residents of this small
city. The general assembly of ECAAS is comprised of two representatives
from each of the 30 neighborhood councils and one representative from
each of the six main social organizations in Saravena. The assembly
elects the administration and sets the policies for ECAAS.
The current water treatment plant was inaugurated in June 1997 and a
plaque lists the names of the eight people that made up the ECAAS administrative
board. Bernardo Arguello was the president. He was imprisoned during
the first mass arrest that took place in Saravena on November 12, 2002.
He has since been released. Luciano Pinto Duran was the vice president.
He later became the president and was arrested in January 2004. He is
still in prison. Edgar Mantilla was killed near the Saravena police
station by two “sicarios” (hired killers) on August 15,
2003. Miguel Pedraza, Silvino Aceros, and Alberto Páez had to
go into hiding when arrest orders were issued for them in 2003.
The sicarios also killed two other ECAAS workers in 2003. Uriel Ortiz
was having a beer with three friends in the El Caney bar on July 22.
Police agents entered the bar and searched Uriel and his companions.
The police asked if one of them worked for ECAAS and Uriel responded
that he did. Five minutes later, two sicarios entered the bar and killed
Uriel and his friends.
Rito Hernandez returned home from his job at ECAAS on September 25,
2003 and went across the street to have a beer with a friend. Two of
Rito’s brothers were in his home that evening and when I met them
in 2004 they described what happened. Two sicarios rode up on bicycles
and one of them shouted “Unionist, son-of-a-bitch!” and
drew his pistol. Rito tried to defend himself with the table but it
couldn’t protect him from the gun. His brothers chased after the
killers and saw them pass a police checkpoint and enter the police station.
I met Rito’s five children during my last day here in Saravena
in 2004 - his youngest daughter was two and his oldest daughter was
nine.
In addition to Bernardo Arguello and Luciano Pinto Duran, ten other
ECAAS workers have been imprisoned. Four workers were imprisoned along
with Bernardo on November 12, 2002. Five more workers were imprisoned
during the next mass arrest in Saravena on August 21, 2003. Another
worker was imprisoned on October 6, 2003.
On March 12 of this year, approximately two dozen Revolutionary Armed
Forces of Colombia (FARC) guerrillas came onto the grounds of the water
treatment plant. They ordered the employees to leave the plant and then
blew up the pipeline that transports water from the plant to Saravena
– leaving the community without clean water for the next four
days.
In spite of all this persecution, the people of ECAAS are continuing
forward with their inspiring work of providing clean and affordable
water for the community. For me, they exemplify the construction of
social justice which is the heart of Saravena.
In love and solidarity,
Scott
August 20, 2006 –The Mass Arrests
Dear friends,
Sixteen people were arrested by the military and police on charges of
“rebellion” and “terrorism” in Fortúl
(15 miles south of Saravena in the state of Arauca) on August 12. The
majority of those people are community leaders and the arrests took
place just days before the August 17 deadline for candidates to register
for the upcoming mayoral election.
During the May 28 presidential elections, the candidate of the left-wing
Alternative Democratic Pole, Carlos Gaviria, received more votes in
Fortúl than did president Uribe. Many people view the arrests
as another attempt by the government to disrupt elections in Arauca.
On October 21, 2003, thirty one political leaders were arrested in Arauca
just five days before municipal and state elections. Father Helmer Muñoz,
who was leading in the polls for the governor’s race, was one
of the people arrested.
I traveled to Arauca City with Juan Carlos, lawyer for the Joel Sierra
Regional Human Rights Committee, on August 14. I was able to talk with
ten of the prisoners from Fortúl who were being held in the Arauca
City police station.
Two teachers, Abdón Goyeneche and William Saenz, were among the
people arrested. Abdón has taught for 22 years and is the president
of the Fortul teachers union. His brother, Leonel, was also a teacher
and the treasurer of the United Workers Federation in Arauca. The Colombian
military murdered Leonel and two other Arauca social leaders on August
5, 2004. Emiro, one of Abdón’s other brothers, was imprisoned
during another mass arrest here in Saravena on August 21, 2003.
Even though Emiro has not been convicted of any crime, he has spent
three years in prison.
“Last night we slept on the ground, chained to the bars, like
dogs” said William - who has been a teacher for 18 years. “Because
I help the poor, I’m considered a terrorist. My fear is that after
I’m released, they’ll come to my house and kill me. That’s
happened with a lot of innocent people.” William and Margarita
have three children – seven, nine, and fifteen years old. William’s
salary is their only income and he’s worried about how the family
will survive while he’s in prison.
When we arrived at the entrance to the Arauca City police station on
August 15, the prisoners from Fortúl had been handcuffed together
and lined up in front of the media. A police agent turned her camera
directly at us and I took out my camera to return the favor. Colonel
Palacios, the police commander, shouted “You can’t take
photos here, this is a military establishment!” “She was
filming me!” I shouted back. I wasn’t able to get the photo
but the agent did stop filming us.
I filed a complaint that afternoon with the director of the government
human rights office in Arauca about being filmed by the agent and the
forced participation of the prisoners in the “press conference.”
That evening the prisoners were shown on the news and Colonel Palacios
described the danger they posed for Arauca.
One of those dangerous individuals is Luz Marina Rodriguez – a
community leader and the mother of 7-month-old Mariangel. “She’s
my first child and I’m going to miss that beautiful process –
her first steps and her first words.”
More than 500 people rallied together in the sports stadium in Fortúl
on August 17 to call for the release of the prisoners. They then marched
through the streets and past the police station where the prisoners
had been held on August 12. Later that afternoon, Maria Gelvez registered
as the candidate of the Alternative Democratic Pole for the September
17 mayoral elections.
In love and solidarity,
Scott
August 6, 2006 –The Massacre
Dear friends,
On the morning of August 5, Fray told me “We’ve got company.”
When I stepped outside of the social organizations’ building here
in Saravena, a tank and an armored personnel carrier were parked across
the street. The cannon of the personnel carrier was pointed towards
the building and the machine gun was pointed towards the corner of the
building. It was an intimidating display of our tax dollars at work
– $3.8 billion in military aid to Colombia since 2000.
August 5 was the second anniversary of the massacre by the Colombian
military of three social leaders here in the state of Arauca –
Alirio Martinez, Jorge Prieto, and Leonel Goyeneche. Alirio was the
president of the Departmental Peasant Association, Jorge was the president
of the Arauca section of the health care workers union, and Leonel was
a teacher and the treasurer of the Arauca section of the United Workers
Federation.
On August 4, 2004, leaders of the Arauca social movement met in the
community of Caño Seco. Alirio and Leonel spent that night in
Jorge’s house. The military came into the community early the
following morning. A civilian informant led three soldiers to Jorge’s
house. The soldiers dragged the three men out of their beds, made them
kneel down, and executed them. Later that day, vice president Santos
and defense minister Uribe said that the three men were guerrillas who
had fired on the soldiers, and the soldiers then fired back killing
them.
The soldiers were members of the Revéiz Pizarro military brigade
based in Saravena. Colonel Francisco Medina was the brigade commander.
I met Medina in July 2004 and he told me he had just returned from a
year of training at Ft. Leavenworth, Kansas.
Two other social leaders were eyewitnesses to the killings in Caño
Seco. Samuel Morales is a teacher and the president of the Arauca section
of the Unified Workers Federation, and Raquel Castro is a teacher and
leader of the teachers union. Samuel and Raquel were detained by the
military and flown to the Saravena military base. When Colonel Medina
saw Samuel he said, “You’re lucky that you saved yourself
because the plan was not to bring you here.” Samuel and Raquel
were imprisoned in Bogotá on the charge of “rebellion.”
They’ve now spent two years in prison even though they haven’t
been convicted of any crime.
There was a national and international outcry in response to the killings.
The three soldiers and the informant, along with the lieutenant in charge
of the operation, have been charged with murder. The Procurator’s
office is also investigating Col. Medina who is suspected of having
ordered the massacre.
Hundreds of people traveled to Caño Seco to commemorate the second
anniversary of the murder of Alirio, Jorge, and Leonel. Aide, one of
Alirio’s daughters, gave the most moving remarks of the ceremony.
She told us, with tears in her eyes and a tremble in her voice, “If
my father was a criminal for working to benefit the community, then
we’re all criminals!” The last time she saw Alirio was in
March 2003 when she left for medical school in Cuba. “My father
had asked me before what I wanted to do, and I had told him that I wanted
to serve our community as a doctor.”
Samuel wrote a letter that was read during the commemoration. “We
feel proud of your legacy. With even greater commitment, we pledge to
continue implementing our alternative plan for development – created
with the wisdom of the indigenous people, the experience of the peasants,
the tenderness of the women, the tenacity of the workers, and the energy
of the students and youth.”
“Alirio, Jorge, and Leonel - Presente! Presente! Presente!”
(They’re here with us!)
In love and solidarity,
Scott
July 30, 2006 –The Displaced
Dear friends,
Luis Carlos is 11-months old and has a congenital heart problem (“soplo”
or inflammation). His parents, Rosalba and Luis Alberto, are part of
the three million “displaced” people here in Colombia –
people who had to flee from their homes to escape the war and repression.
The family is currently living in Arauca City and I met them at the
Permanent Human Rights Committee office there on July 26.
Rosalba and Luis Alberto managed to work their way through the bureaucratic
maze and officially register as displaced people. As such, the family
is entitled to government-subsidized health care through a private company
- Caprecon. The doctor says that Luis Carlos needs an electrocardiogram
(EKG) but none of the public hospitals in the state of Arauca have that
equipment. Caprecon made an appointment for Luis Carlos to have an EKG
in the public hospital in Bucaramanga (15 hours west of Arauca City
by bus) for July 28, but the company refused to cover any of the travel
costs.
Pedro is a member of the Permanent Human Rights Committee and a leader
of the organization of displaced people in Arauca – we met him
during our delegation here last year. He and I accompanied Rosalba and
Luis Carlos to the Social Action office – the Colombian government
program for the displaced. We were told that Caprecon is supposed to
provide “integral” health care which would include the travel
costs to Bucaramanga, so Social Action wouldn’t help with those
costs. They suggested that we go to the government Human Rights Defenders
office. The woman there called the national Red Cross, international
Red Cross, mayor’s office, and the governor’s office but
no one offered to help with the travel costs. The local expression that
describes my feelings is “It nearly broke my soul.” (“Casi
me partió el alma.”)
On July 27, the Arauca legislature debated the budget for the “Governor’s
Office and Citizen Security” – which includes support for
the displaced. Nearly 100 displaced people gathered in the central plaza
to march to the legislature. The police started harassing them and threatening
to take away their bicycles if they didn’t leave the plaza. Pedro
began dialoging with the police while I took a few photos, and things
calmed down a bit. As soon as we arrived at the steps to the legislature
a DAS (security and immigration police) agent demanded to see my identification
papers. I showed him my passport (with volunteer visa!) and a letter
of support from Senator Baucus. He reviewed my passport and made a copy
of the letter, and then told me that my documents were in order and
everything was fine.
The governor’s secretary reviewed the 2006 budget for the Governor’s
Office and Citizen Security. The budget includes $667,000 for the government
security forces and $542,000 for a military base, and just $104,000
for the displaced. Pedro told me that there are 1,600 displaced families
in Arauca.
Pedro is risking his life by speaking out on behalf of the displaced
in Arauca. On March 11, three armed “civilians” were watching
his house. Pedro called the police and the men identified themselves
as off-duty soldiers. Four days later, Pedro was followed from the central
plaza to the Social Action office. Pedro couldn’t return to his
house and he stayed for several days in the Permanent Human Rights Committee
office. The committee sent an action alert about the situation and I
contacted the commander of the 18th Military Brigade to express our
concern. Pedro said, “Your response was beautiful.” The
commander of the base called Pedro to a meeting and asked how people
in the United States knew about his situation. Pedro responded, “We’re
family.”
In love and solidarity,
Scott
July 25, 2006
Dear friends,
One of the most deadly professions in Colombia is education. I visited
Arauca City (100 miles east of Saravena in the state of Arauca) from
July 17 to 19, and I met with leaders of the Arauca Teachers Union.
Jaime Carrillo, human rights coordinator for the union, gave me a list
of the 28 teachers who have been killed in Arauca since 1980 - nineteen
of those murders took place in the last five years. “I knew most
of those people,” said Jaime. Another 125 teachers have been threatened
with death – five percent of the 2,456 teachers employed by the
state of Arauca.
Jaime has been receiving death threats from the right-wing paramilitaries
(which have close relations with the Colombian military) since 1991.
In January 2004, anti-union graffiti was painted on a high school and
the house of the union president, flyers with death threats against
the union leaders were thrown in the streets, and a letter expressing
condolence for Jaime’s death was slipped under the front door
of his house. Jaime fled to Bogotá for a while and then flew
back to Arauca City on March 8. As soon as he arrived home from the
airport, two paramilitaries came to the house asking for him. That same
month, he received a message that stated, “Watch out for your
children or you’ll never see them again.”
It wasn’t safe for Jaime to stay in his home, so he spent the
next six months living in the union office. My first trip to Arauca
was with an international delegation in June 2004. We flew from Bogotá
to Arauca City and had a brief meeting that evening in the union office
– where Jaime was staying. One day, some of his friends invited
him to leave the office to have lunch with them. As soon as Jaime sat
down at the table, his cell phone rang and the caller told him, “We’re
watching you.” On May 18, June 18, and July 18 of 2005, threatening
materials were slipped under the front door of his house.
Jaime told me that he is one of the five remaining members of the board
of directors of the Unified Workers Federation in Arauca. Samuel Morales,
a teacher and the federation president, is in prison in Bogotá
on charges of “rebellion.” Alfonso Campino was released
from prison last month for medical reasons – he was also held
on charges of “rebellion.” The federation auditor went into
hiding to avoid arrest on charges of “rebellion.” Leonel
Goyeneche, a teacher and the federation treasurer, was murdered by the
Colombian military on August 4, 2004.
The Arauca Teachers Union office has an armored door, bulletproof windows,
and video camera surveillance; and Jaime moves around Arauca City with
two armed bodyguards. He said, “I sense that I could be the victim
of a bombing and I worry about my wife.” Carmen has also been
mentioned in the threats against Jaime. In spite of all this, Jaime
says “I’ve lived all of my life here in Arauca and I’m
going to continue forward with this work.”
One of several inspiring educational projects in Arauca is the Parmenio
Bonilla High School in Puerto Nidia. Parmenio was the director of the
Puerto Nidia high school and he was killed on his way to the school
in 1993. The high school was created by the peasant families in the
region and it provides a quality education for the children that come
from “satellite” elementary schools in their communities.
My friend Raquel Castro, who is in prison in Bogotá on charges
of “rebellion,” was the director of the school. When I visited
her on July 1, she showed me an album of photos of the school and explained
the improvements they had made while she was director. Eudoro, another
friend, is the current director and I saw him again this afternoon –
he said the school is continuing to function very well.
In love and solidarity,
Scott
July 16, 2006
Dear friends,
The people here in the state of Arauca (northeastern Colombia) are saying
“the situation is very complicated.” In March, one of the
local leaders of the National Army of Liberation (ELN) guerrillas killed
a leader of the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC) guerrillas.
The two groups have been fighting in Arauca since then, and they have
done a much more effective job of killing each other than the Colombian
and U.S. military had been able to do in the past several years. This
would appear to be an example of the inherent danger that results from
mixing high levels of testosterone with large amounts of guns.
The two groups have also been threatening civilians that they perceive
as being aligned with the other group. Twenty six community leaders
that were threatened by the FARC have sought refuge here in the city
of Saravena. Several of them are staying in the social organizations’
building – which is also where I’m staying.
International accompaniment doesn’t provide any security in this
type of confrontation. I arrived here on July 10 and by the following
day I was considering an early return to Bogotá – a brief
display of common sense.
Since then, I’ve talked with a lot of friends from different social
organizations in Arauca. They described how important international
accompaniment has been in preventing abuses by the Colombian military
and police, and they expressed their concern that the government could
be preparing another series of mass arrests in Arauca. They also told
me about their plans to continue their efforts to achieve peace with
social justice, even in the midst of this “very complicated situation.”
So, for now, I’m still in Saravena and I’ll probably be
here for a month before returning to Bogotá to re-evaluate things
from there.
On July 15, I travelled with Rigoberto (a friend from the Agrarian Union)
to Puerto Lleras – a small community about 40 minutes from here
alongside the Arauca River. Occidental Petroleum has a large oilfield
in Caño Limón (30 miles east of Saravena) that produces
100,000 barrels a day. That wealth leaves the department via a pipeline
that passes very close to where we traveled.
We left Saravena on the main “highway” in Arauca –
dodging potholes on Rigoberto’s motorcycle and bouncing along
sections of the road where the asphalt had washed away. We then turned
on to a “secondary road” – a kidney-jarring mix of
dirt and rocks. As we arrived in Puerto Lleras, we rode past the health
center – staffed by a nurse, but lacking medicine and medical
equipment. We met with the community in the school – where there
is just one teacher for the more than 50 students in first through fifth
grade.
Members of the community expressed their concerns about the abuses they’ve
suffered from the military. Soldiers occupy houses which puts the people
at risk of being caught in the middle of any confrontation with the
guerrillas. They had to abandon Puerto Lleras for eight months because
of that fighting, but most of the people have now returned. Several
members of the community have been detained and imprisoned on charges
of “rebellion.” Andres spent 18 months and 20 days in the
Arauca City prison before he was released because there wasn’t
any evidence against him. Pedro spent a year in that same prison before
he was also released because of a lack of evidence.
The slogan of the Arauca social organizations is “Arauca exists,
insists, and resists!” and our compañeras and compañeros
here are continuing forward in the struggle for peace with social justice.
With love and solidarity.
Scott
July 9, 2006
Dear friends,
I arrived here in Bogotá on June 30 and I went to prison the
following day (to visit a friend). Before I tell you about the visit
with Raquel, I want to let you know that I’ll be using this address
– elmonogringo@hotmail.com – during the year that I’ll
be here in Colombia (“el mono gringo” translates as “the
whitey gringo”).
I also want to express my appreciation to all the organizations that
are supporting my accompaniment work in Colombia – Global Ministries
of the United Church of Christ and the Disciples of Christ, Justice
and Witness Ministries of the United Church of Christ, University Congregational
Church, Montana Human Rights Network, Progressive Labor Caucus, Community
Action for Justice in the Americas, and the Missoula Central Labor Council.
I also want to thank my one corporate sponsor – Banana Boat Sunscreen.
Raquel Castro is a teacher and a leader of the social movement in the
state of Arauca (northeastern Colombia). Various social leaders from
Arauca met in the community of Caño Seco on August 4, 2004. Alirio
Martinez (president of the Departmental Peasant Association), Leonel
Goyeneche (treasurer of the United Workers Federation in Arauca), and
Raquel spent that night in the house of Jorge Prieto (president of the
health care workers union in Arauca). The following morning, the military
occupied Caño Seco.
An informant led three soldiers to Jorge’s house. The soldiers
dragged Alirio, Leonel, and Jorge out of bed; took them outside; made
them kneel down; and executed them. “I heard a long burst of gunfire,”
said Raquel. “I tried to convince myself that the soldiers had
just fired into the air, that they hadn’t really killed my compañeros.
Then the soldiers came into my room and shined their flashlights on
my face. They pointed their guns at me and ordered me to go outside.
I was sure that my life had ended. I was walking, but my feet weren’t
touching the ground – it was like I was floating. There were a
lot of soldiers outside the house. One of them yelled, ‘Go back
inside! Don’t come out!’ and that saved my life. Otherwise,
I would have been killed alongside the bodies of my compañeros.”
Raquel’s life was miraculously spared that day but she was detained
by the soldiers. She was flown to the Reveis Pizarro military base in
the city of Saravena. “When I got off the helicopter, I saw a
lot of U.S. soldiers. I remember the look on their faces. They were
laughing and making fun of me.” She was then flown to Bogotá
and sent to the “Good Shepherd” prison on charges of rebellion
and terrorism. The public hearing for her case was held in Saravena
last August (where I took the attached photo). The case was then transferred
to a judge in Bogotá who has not yet reached a verdict. Raquel
has now spent 23 months in prison.
I visited Raquel on July 1 and July 8. She’s being held in the
maximum security wing of the prison. In order to enter the prison and
pass through the various checkpoints, my arms were stamped six times
and my fingerprint was taken. On July 1, I was stamped with number 123;
and on July 8, I was stamped with number 237.
Raquel is an amazing and very inspiring person. “I was born to
be with the people. I don’t regret what I’ve done although
perhaps I could have done more. We denounced the abuses and human rights
violations committed against the civilian population. That’s why
they killed our compañeros and threw us in prison.”
“I believe that my time here (in prison) has been more positive
than negative. I’ve become more tranquil and reflective in this
confinement. I’ve dared to say things that I never said before.
I’m living new experiences and I’m learning other ways of
expressing and seeing life.”
Raquel’s vocation is teaching and she’s continuing her vocation
in prison. She and some of the other women began teaching classes in
April and they now have 450 students. Their goal is to create a government-recognized
school within the prison that will go from first grade through high
school. “They accuse me of a lot of things that I don’t
even know about. What I do know how to do is teach classes.”
On July 10, I’ll be flying to Saravena to accompany the social
organizations of Arauca.
In love and solidarity,
Scott
Community Action for Justice in the Americas
Updates from Venezuela
Dave Jones is a CAJA member and spent two weeks in Venezuela on
a Witness for Peace Delegation
Witness in Venezuela
6/1/06
While I had been aware of the many negative impacts of US intervention
in Latin America throughout the Cold War years, it was not until joining
CAJA two years ago that I began to educate myself more fully on current
policy and to keep up with more recent events. Hearing of travels by
other members inspired my wife Char and I to join the first Witness
for Peace delegation to Venezuela in late February in order to gain
a deeper understanding of the new social movement developing there and
US reaction to it.
Government officials and the mainstream media in general have been
engaged in a propaganda effort to discredit and distort the political
situation in Venezuela for several years, and this effort has intensified
recently following the criticism leveled at US policy by Venezuelan
president Hugo Chavez. Our delegation was an effort to sort out facts
from opinion, truth from hyperbole, and to get the views of as many
interested parties as possible in ten days so that we could begin to
draw our own informed conclusions.
When Margaret Thatcher famously said that "there are no alternatives"
to the neo-liberal capitalist model, she was not-so-subtly referring
to the resolve of western governments to enforce a hegemonic economic
order put into place at the end of the second World War. Development
loans would require that national assets be privatized and sold off
to the highest bidder, unions were to be busted, economies were to be
oriented toward cheap exports for northern consumers, and governments
were to be "clients" of the major powers and their corporate
handlers. The Venezuelan people, led by the fiery Chavez, have rejected
this model.
Through a unique process of revolution by referendum, the people of
Venezuela are creating a true alternative focused on raising the living
standards and opportunity of those ignored and left behind by past governments.
Although the country is rich in oil wealth, the vast majority of citizens
saw little or no benefit while a small, elite oligarchy enjoyed a fabulous
lifestyle. The mostly lighter skinned families of European descent controlling
this wealth were supported by their major customer, the United States,
and US and European oil firms were able to extract large profits for
many decades. This all changed when the new Venezuelan constitution
declared that the oil belonged to the people and the wealth derived
from its sale was to be devoted to improving the lives of the poorest,
which are the vast majority, of these citizens.
The competent and effective Witness for Peace team was able to arrange
a wide range of interviews with those representing the interests of
many segments of Venezuelan society, from academics to government officials
to workers. We heard from supporters of the Bolivarian Revolution, and
those in opposition to it, and those who were somewhere in the middle,
perhaps critical of some aspects yet pleased with others. As I engage
in conversations about this trip with those I meet in my daily life,
I am constantly amazed at how uninformed or completely misinformed most
US citizens are about the new political movement of Venezuela. My personal
experience hopefully can counter some of this and help me to be an effective
advocate for the right of the Venezuelan people to self-determination
without US interference.
Joe Hayes is a CAJA member and spent 4 months in Venezuela this
year.
3/1/06
Las Misiónes of a Venezuelan Barrio
Last week I went on a tour through a barrio in the Venezuelan city
of Mérida to observe the work of the government’s social
missions, las misiónes, and their impact on the communities they
serve. The tour was led by a U.S. graduate student in political science
who is beginning his master’s program at the University of the
Andes here in Mérida and has worked in community organizing in
this barrio for six months. The government’s misiónes address
a wide range of problems, from tackling illiteracy and overall lack
of education for the poor while reforming the system already in place,
addressing immediate health and food needs while building long term
solutions, land reform designed to empower previously displaced indigenous
populations and other poor majorities, and building economies of worker-owned
cooperatives through education, technical assistance and funding. Las
Misiónes are funded entirely by oil money, and are a first bold
step toward reducing the gross inequity that is the reality of Venezuela.
Over half the population of Venezuela lives in barrios. Barrios are
the equivalent of shanty towns, and are defined by the fact that they
are built by those who live in them and are in no way planned developments.
They are often structurally unsound and built on the hillsides surrounding
Venezuelan cities, creating a dangerous situation. Hundreds of people
die every year during the rainy season as the hillsides upon which these
neighborhoods are built lose their grasp and tumble downward. This danger
was realized more fully in 1999, when heavy rains caused massive landslides,
resulting in the deaths of 15,000 to 20,000 people, and leaving close
to 100,000 homeless. The barrio we visited sprawls across a hillside
overlooking the city, and holds 3,000 residents.
We first stopped at the Bolivarian school at the top of the hillside.
This school is designed by the government to improve the lives of both
the students and their parents by providing a full day of education,
rather than the half-day public schools of the pre-Chávez days.
Under the old system, children could attend school during the morning
or afternoon only, giving them much time for watching television and
requiring parents to stay home and care for children, unable to get
jobs. The school we visited holds grades 1-6 and has over one hundred
students. They are served three full meals a day, which are cooked by
mothers of the students in the new school kitchen and who receive a
small stipend. The morning programming revolves around more traditional
academics, while the afternoon programming focuses on athletics, art,
and cultural education. The process of converting schools from the pre-Chávez
public schools to the Bolivarian school is gradual, as faculties work
to build up their school’s ability to run all day and only make
the change to the Bolivarian model after a majority faculty vote. This
helps to ensure schools will make a successful conversion and upholds
democratic values on a local level, allowing those most affected by
the changes to make the actual decisions. Schools first started making
the change in 1999, and the pace has been increasing ever since. In
Mérida state over 2000 schools made the change in 2005, and they
are nearing the 50% mark.
Venezuela also has programs addressing the widespread poverty of the
country and is working to alleviate immediate hunger needs while establishing
tangible and realistic long term solutions. This effort is felt in the
barrio by the presence of a Misión Mercal and a Casa de Alimentación,
or soup kitchen. We next visited a Mercal, which is a market that sells
most of what would be found in typical markets throughout Venezuela
at a subsidized rate of 40-50% off normal prices. In working to create
greater food sustainability within the country and rely less on food
imports for sustaining the population, at least 70% of the food at Mercals
is required to be produced in Venezuela. And much of this food produced
in the country is grown and processed by cooperatives. These markets
may be one of the most prominent misiónes visible as one travels
the country, for everywhere I go I see Mercal markets. Over half the
Venezuelan population buys their food at Mercal. Down the hill from
the Mercal market is a Casa de Alimentación. This soup kitchen
is in the front of a woman’s house who offered her space for this
function. There are government issued refrigerators, stoves, and ovens.
A census was taken in this community of 3,000, and the soup kitchen
is meant to serve the 150 most in need.
Next we stopped where there are typically two Cuban doctors who stay
in the house of another resident who volunteered his home for a misión.
Unfortunately we couldn’t talk with the doctors because they had
returned home for a visit with their families. Throughout the country
there are dispersed over 13,000 Cuban doctors as part of Misión
Barrio Adentro, or Into the Barrio, who provide the most basic medical
care to those who before had no access. These doctors see patients from
the barrio in the front of the house for primary diagnosis and prescribe
further care in an advanced medical facility when needed. They focus
largely on preventative medicine, and most of their equipment and drugs
come directly from Cuba. The infrastructure for advanced medical facilities
outside of the previous, and currently still functioning, private medical
system is currently being developed, as we saw as we made our way back
to the city center.
On out way back we stopped at Misión Barrio Adentro 2, which
is an urgent care and emergency medical facility free to both Venezuelans
and foreigners alike. Here we spoke with a doctor and paramedic, where
we learned about the capabilities of this new facility and the aspirations
of this misión. As of now, over 150 of these facilities have
been built around the country, three of which are in the small state
of Mérida. The government plans to create a total of 600. Alberto,
the paramedic, had been trained in Cuba, and was also one of the first
of over 14,000 Latin Americans to receive eye surgery in Cuba free of
travel and medical expenses. Because of Cuba’s cooperation, Alberto’s
cataracts have been cured and he is now able to serve as an ambulance
driver and paramedic. During our visit the clinic was in the process
of acquiring the equipment needed for the best possible care, and will
soon be able to perform emergency brain and heart surgery.
These misiónes I visited are just some of the many social programs
created by the innovative socialist government of Hugo Chávez,
and their impacts on the quality of life for the overwhelmingly poor
majority are immeasurable.
1/31/2006
The World Social Forum in a Polarized Caracas
As the first phase of my travels in Venezuela comes to a close with
the end of the World Social Forum in Caracas, I am left with a strong
desire to learn as much as I can about this country's people, politics,
and strivings toward a more egalitarian and dignified society. The World
Social Forum is a gathering of people and organizations from around
the world that recognize the destructive consequences of neoliberal
(a.k.a. corporate gloablaization) economic policy and seek a more equitable
system. The forum provides a place for ideas to be exchanged, global
networks to be created, and action to be taken, with the ultimate goal
of uniting the people of the world and building alternatives to neoliberal
policy and the domination of capital in decision making.
At the turn of the millennium, the people of this oil rich country
were considered anything but rich. A common estimate suggested eighty
percent of Venezuelans were poor. But this figure is changing and improving
in significant ways, and the Bolivarian Revolution taking place in this
country made Caracas an ideal place for the World Social Forum. This
Bolivarian Revolution, lead by the democratically elected president
Hugo Chávez, has created a socialist revolution within a capitalist
country. This ongoing process has caused great polarization. Chavistas
demonstrate their support of Chávez and his social missions, funded
entirely by oil money, which aim to alleviate both the short term and
long term problems of poverty and maldevelopment. The opposition, which
has more or less dissolved as an electoral political force, is made
up of the small middle and upper classes and continues to argue against
the changes taking place in this country through the mass media, its
main source of influence.
Initially, I was surprised to meet people without strong opinions about
Chávez and the changes of this country. Their general opinions questioned
the future of this revolution, but they nonetheless reflected on the
importance of the middle class's increased awareness of widespread poverty
both within the country and around the world. But as I got to know Caracas
better I learned where to find the polarized views. The atmosphere of
the World Social Forum was enthusiastic about Chávez and his challenge
of neoliberalism, and this was felt from the street vendors selling
Chávez posters and t-shirts alongside the Che Guevara merchandise to
the forum events discussing the future of Bolivarianism and how global
networks of support could be created in solidarity. A five minute surf
of Caracas television gave a different view, which, besides the state
owned channel 8, made every attempt to tie the grave news stories of
the day to failures of the Chávez administration.
Within this dynamic I had many touching experiences. This being my
first experience traveling in South America and having inadequate Spanish
speaking skills, I made the most of my time at the forum getting to
know the different kinds of movements and organizations working around
the world and their role at the forum. I found great significance in
the presence of the Poor People's Economic Human Rights Campaign-- a
network of groups working against poverty in the United States. This
organization could only afford to send two delegates to the forum, but
was fortunate enough to bring 100 delegates from all over the U.S. at
the invitation and expense of the Venezuelan government. This action
is another example of the Chávez administration's commitment to addressing
poverty in Venezuela and throughout the world, and helps to empower
the Venezuelan people by increasing their understanding of a world with
systemic poverty in both underdeveloped and developed nations.
Also interesting was a walk through Plaza Altamira, in an upper-middle
class neighborhood of eastern Caracas. The Caraqueños here did not hesitate
at the chance to express their opinions of Chávez to Forum-goers, one
of whom was a middle-aged man, an architect by training, who had been
out of work for five years. He lambasted Chávez for making such dramatic
changes while ignoring the needs of the middle class, while older women
spoke frantically of their fear that Venezuela would become the next
Cuba. As I left Altamira and rode the metro to a less affluent part
of town, I remember thinking they all looked well fed.
In stark contrast to the stroll through a clean and well-lit plaza
was the tour I stumbled across through a relatively safe barrio on a
hillside on the outskirts of Caracas. The tour began with a community
organizer who passionately explained that, though Chávez's social missions
are expanding the number of cooperatives in Venezuela exponentially,
their community had organized its cooperative market well before Chávez
was on the political scene. It is necessary to realize many of the most
successful cooperatives are running not because of government support,
but because people have organized their communities to create better
lives for themselves. Seeing the pride and empowerment these people
felt through their collective action surely gives credence to possibility
of a mass-based cooperative society as an alternative to capitalism.
Chávez's Misión Vuelvan Caras, or “Mission Turn Around,” is aiming to
do just that, and is providing the education and resources necessary
for the creation of a society of cooperativism and with an economy of
equity and dignity. I am energized to learn more.